Let’s get started with The GIMP

When talking about imaging on Linux, you won’t be able to ignore The Gimp for long. Love it or hate it. Actually, Gimp vs Photoshop is a bit like Apple vs PC, Linux vs Windows, Canon vs Nikon (I am Pentax, btw) or ManU vs ManCity: lots of whining, rants, trolling and flaming. So let’s have a look at The Gimp with a photographer’s eye.

The Gimp (web, wiki) has been one of the first widely distributed, successful open source program; it has been part of any Linux distribution for as long as one can remember and it still is. Development has had its ups and down and is now close to a 2.4 release, which we’ll use as a basis for this entry. I don’t intend to do a detailed report, just to highlight a few dot points from a photographer’s point of view.

The interface

One of the most controversial facet of The Gimp is its interface: the programs opens several window when used, one for your picture, one for the tools, one for the layers… I rather like that since it gives more freedom to put your picture on one screen and your tools on the other one and since we’re talking about Linux, you can devote one virtual screen to The Gimp. Mind you, I never extensively worked with Photoshop since:

  1. I am on Linux🙂
  2. I’d rather buy a new lens than a box of software…

Nifty features

The 2.4 version brings quite a few new / nifty features, like a great way to select / crop rectangular regions (flexible and easy), a nice channel mixer to produce black and white images, color management (more on that later) , an enhanced Text engine and a nice preview of image rotation.

There has also been a reorganisation in the menus that make them more logical even if not perfect…

Not quite there yet features

The Gimp supports layers but no effect layers. So you cannot go back to your “brightness and contrast” settings and touch it up later. You have to use the “undo”, which is no way as flexible.

The Gimp also supports a lot of scripts that allow you to do about anything like drop shadows, drawing flames or giving a “glow” look to your image. Few are really useful for photography, except (maybe) red-eyes removal, unsharp mask (this one definitely), blurs (for masks and selections). There is also a Noise Reduction dialog (but not as powerful as NoiseNinja or Noiseware) and that’s about the ones I use.

Where the deal falls through

The problem with The Gimp is that it only processes images with 8bits / channel. So you have 256 nuances of Red Green Blue or (in case of grayscale) 256 nuances from black to white. This is roughly as much nuance our human eye can distinguish so it is fine in theory, but in practice, when you start correcting your image with curves, levels (you name it), you end up with 230, 200 or so levels and you have visible degradation in your gradients (skies…). It is even worse with black and white.

So that makes The Gimp a “no-no” for any serious photographic work under Linux. I only use it for a “quick and dirty” touch up of a image just to see how it would look when croped and touched up, but any “serious processing” (for printing or archiving) is not done in The Gimp.

Future hopes

There is an ambitious project called GEGL (web, wiki) which is an image manipulation library. The idea is that you apply operations (say brightness/contrast) to your base image and get the final output either on screen or saved in a file. The beauty of it is that you can modify, add or suppress operations (think “effect layer”) and that your base image is not changed (think “Nikon capture”). And this library works internally in 32bits floating point (think “millions of nuances in Red Green Blue”). That library is going to be at the heart of the next iteration of The Gimp (2.6, but I would bump it to 3.0🙂 ).

There is also a big effort going on in a rethink of the user interface (web) to be implemented in the next iteration, so there is much to look forward to.

Final thoughts

The Gimp has great perspectives with GEGL (overcoming its 8bits limitation) and a UI redesign. However, remember that Gimp is an open source project with people working in it “when they have time”. So this can mean that the next iteration is in a quite distant future.

I think The Gimp has also a problem defining itself: is it a tool for photographers, for web designers, for icon designers? I would say that quite a bit of the confusion regarding the UI is due to that. There is no way to have an easy fitting-to-all interface if the software behind is complex and offers lots of possibilities (and powerful photographic software is quite complex, although not as much as, say, 3D modelling).

So good things to look forward to, with a grain (or two) of salt…

7 Responses to Let’s get started with The GIMP

  1. Jan says:

    Thx a lot, never thought that there is such a difference. May I assume that Photoshop has more than 8 bit per channel (right now)?

  2. jcornuz says:

    Hi Jan,

    Yes Photoshop supports 16bits / channel – but it has been a long process to move away from 8 bits with more and more tools supporting 16bits with each new version. Looking forward to what will come out of GEGL integration in Gimp…

    Take care,

    Joel

  3. Harsh says:

    Hi… that was a really great article… i have just been ‘forced’ to use white-box linux and i was thinking how can i ever get to edit photos as I did with Photoshop… then I found GIMP… but There is still one ‘big’ porblem : The UI… Hope they refine it…

    And yeah… In the opening Para, it should be : Man Utd vs say Arsenal or Chelsea… Man Utd are such a great team, while City dont ever pose any threat to the title…

  4. George Yotov says:

    You can’t beat Photoshop.

  5. DoubleDee says:

    Your list of articles…as found here https://jcornuz.wordpress.com/category/software/ are exactly what I googled for. I use PhotoFiltre in windows… Gimp, Adobe PhotoShop and Elements are too much for for what I want and for some reason I can’t get CinePaint to work in PcLinuxOs 2010…grrr…

    Don’t know what to do or the replacement programs out there so I’m gonna read your articles…I’ll leave a comment on the last article…..

  6. sky 3d says:

    I am really glad to see that you are putting so much of effort for encouraging the visitors , Ohhh what do you all think about 3d tv?

  7. Frédéric COIGNOT -photographe dijon…

    […]Let’s get started with The GIMP « Linux Photography[…]…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: